September’s book of the month is John Bunyan’s classic Pilgrim’s Progress. I have heard (although never verified) that the Bible is the only book in history to be translated into more languages or sold more copies than Pilgrim’s Progress. English pastor John Newton, of Amazing Grace fame, read it so often that he memorized it. He spent over 2 years lecturing through it on Tuesday nights. The book as had a lasting impact on generations of Christians.

John Bunyan (1628-1688) was a tinkerer, meaning he fixed pots and pans and other household items made of metal for a living. He was also a flagrant sinner. Yet God had set him aside for an important work that continues to bear fruit today. Bunyan’s conversion was gradual, and the early days of his pilgrimage were marked by doubt. Yet God’s irresistible grace proved greater than these challenges. Eventually, Bunyan would become a famous Baptist preacher, author, and sufferer for Christ.

Bunyan lived during a time when English law required everyone to attend services in the Church of England at least once a month. Failure to do so could lead to arrest or even exile. It was also illegal to preach without a government license. Dissenting congregations, like the Baptists, Congregationalists, and Presbyterians were illegal. Bunyan would spend 9 years in prison for preaching without a license. Yet God causes all things to work together for good to those who love God, to those who are called according to His purposes (Ro. 8:28). Just like Joseph in the OT, God had a plan for Bunyan’s imprisonment, for it was here that he wrote his famous allegory.

Pilgrim’s Progress narrates Christian’s journey from the City of Destruction to the Celestial City. It is an allegory of the Christian life, in which Bunyan demonstrates two great qualities. First, he demonstrated piercing insight into human nature. Characters like Pliable, Talkative, Faithful, Hopeful, Evangelist, Doubtful, and many more capture human qualities and weaknesses in a way that helps us understand ourselves and others.

Second, Bunyan had a masterful understanding of how hard faithfulness to Christ can be. Slough of Despond (despair), Vanity Fair, Doubters Castle, and Bypath Meadow all represent dangers we face as Christians. Through Christian’s victories and failures, we learn what it means to live as aliens and sojourners in the world.

Although I am not an enthusiast at the level as John Newton, I do think every Christian would benefit from reading Bunyan’s classic. I find myself returning to it every five years or so. Each time I read it, my appreciation for its insights grows. I also find myself referencing it more frequently in sermons than I used to. 

Because the book is past copywrite laws, there are many versions available. Not all of them are quality versions, so buying the cheapest version on Amazon may prove to be a disappointment. So read the reviews before you buy a copy. There are wonderful adaptations available for children. I have used Tyler Van Halteren’s Little Pilgrim’s Big Journey more than once for family devotions. There are also quality abridgements available that modernize the English. If you have never read a book from the 1600s before, I would recommend one of these, as 400-year-old English can be hard to follow. If you read it, you will join countless Christians helped along their own pilgrimage through Bunyan’s insightful allegory of the Christian life.

Mark 1:15 summarizes the content of Jesus’ first sermons in this way: the time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand; repent and believe the gospel. By starting his public ministry with these words, Jesus was aligning with another preacher his listeners were familiar with. Matthew 3:2 summarizes John the Baptist’s preaching with these words: repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand. Jesus’ call to repentance indicates that He was continuing the work started by John. It should be no surprise then, when Peter’s first sermon ended by telling people to repent. He was simply preaching the same message as John and Jesus. 

Repentance is an important but often neglected part of our response to the gospel. Since the Bible commands everyone to repent, we would be wise to understand what it means to do so.

Repentance is more than feeling sorry for what you have done. It includes that, but repentance is more than remorse. Repentance means you stop going in your current direction in order to go in an entirely different direction. A great illustration of this principle is found in Exodus 32. Israel had sinned by making the golden calf. God, who was rightly angry with them for it, told Moses that He was going to wipe them out and start over with him. Moses interceded for the people. In response to his prayer, we are told in Exodus 32:14, so the Lord relented from the harm which He said He would do to His people (NKJV). The KJV gives a more literal translation when it says that the Lord repented of the evil He intended against His people. God intended to do one thing but responded to Moses’ intercession by doing the opposite.

Now obviously, God is neither tempted by or capable of sin, so the ‘repentance’ He expressed is different than a sinner’s repentance. But His relenting of harm in order to do good to His people helps us understand repentance. Before salvation, we are slaves of sin, captured by Satan, bound to do his will, and willfully rebelling against God. When we repent, we relent of our rebellion, turn from sin, and follow Christ in loving submission. Repentance is the letting go of our former way of life to live by faith in the Son of God. If salvation were a coin, faith would be the face and repentance the tail. Both are our response to God’s gift of salvation, which is why Jesus said to repent and believe the gospel (Mk. 1:15).

The Bible draws our attention to three important aspects of repentance. First, repentance recognizes how sin is ultimately the violation God’s character. Psalm 51 records David’s repentance of his sinful actions in the matter with Bathsheba. In vs. 4 we read against You, You only, I have sinned, and done what is evil in Your sight, so that You are justified when You speak and blameless when You judge. What does he mean he sinned against God only? What about Bathsheba? Scholars debate if she was a willing participant or unfortunate victim in the affair. Regardless, David had led her to violate her marriage covenant. What about Uriah? He was the victim of David’s adulterous actions and then of his murderous plan. What about the nation? As king, David was the shepherd of Israel. Had his sin not violated the nation’s trust? The answer is yes each of these; yet David says that, despite each of these offenses, the real problem was that he had violated God’s character. Until we realize the spiritual treason sin is against the eternal goodness of God, true repentance will not happen.

Second, repentance is preceded by godly sorrow. In 2 Corinthians 7:8-10, we learn that Paul sent the church at Corinth a letter that had upset them. Some accused him of being too harsh in his correction. Yet Paul responded by saying for though I caused you sorrow by my letter, I do not regret it; through I did regret it—for I see that that letter caused you sorrow, though only for a while—I now rejoice, not that you were made sorrowful, but that you were made sorrowful to the point of repentance; for you were made sorrowful according to the will of God, so that you might not suffer loss in anything through us. For the sorrow that is according to the will of God produces a repentance without regret, leading to salvation, but the sorrow of the world produces death.

There are two kinds of sorrow. Worldly sorrow that leads to death and godly sorrow that produces repentance. It is not uncommon as a pastor for people to seek my help dealing with a sinful habit. Oftentimes, these conversations are preceded by the individual ‘getting caught’ by someone. Some of these individuals are truly broken over their sin and want victory. They have a godly sorrow. Others come to see me because a parent or spouse told them they had to. They regret how their actions have created discomfort and are doing what they must to make it all go away. This is worldly sorrow. Unsurprisingly, those who experience godly sorrow often go on to have victory over their sin because they experience true repentance, while those who try to make the situation go away rarely experience lasting change because their hearts have not changed. Their sorrow is over how sin affects them personally, not for how it offends God. Repentance starts with a change of heart that leads to changed behavior. 

Finally, repentance is a gift of God. In 2 Timothy 2:25-26 Paul tells Timothy to gently correct those who are in error so that perhaps God may grant them repentance leading to the knowledge of the truth, and they may come to their senses and escape from the snare of the devil, having been held captive by him to do his will.  According to this verse, repentance is something God gives. That means it is a part of His gracious working within us.

Now, in saying that repentance is a gift we receive from God does not mean we are to be passive about it. The opposite is true. We are to seek it from the Lord who wants to be gracious towards us. Isaiah 55:6-7 tells us to seek the Lord while He may be found; call upon Him while He is near. Let the wicked forsake His way and the unrighteous man his thoughts; and let him return to the Lord, and He will have compassion on him, and to our God, for He will abundantly pardon.

The bible presents two parallel, non-contradicting truths. First, repentance is a part of God’s gracious working in salvation. He must grant it to us. Second, we are to seek God and call upon His name, trusting Him to do the work He has promised to do. As we do, God will work His grace in us, including giving us the gift of repentance. God never denies the experience of His grace to anyone who truly seeks Him.

John Calvin once observed that all the Christian life is repentance. By that he meant that after salvation, Christians are engaged in the lifelong process of turning away from their former life of sin to follow Jesus. May we be the kinds of Christians who seek the Lord with a whole heart while fleeing sin.  

What are the Nine Marks?

Mark Dever identifies 9 that cultivate spiritual health in a church. The first mark is expository preaching. Expository preaching begins with the conviction that God’s word is sufficient to build the church. Therefore, the preacher seeks to draw the meaning out of the text and show people how it applies to their lives.

The second mark is biblical theology. It is great to understand individual passages and to plumb the depths of a Bible book. But a healthy church also seeks to understand the broader narrative of God’s word so they can develop a balanced theology of God, man, sin, salvation, and the Christian life.

Third is a proper understanding of the gospel. If we do not properly understand the gospel, we will short-circuit our Christian walk, create confusion in our evangelistic efforts, and run the risk of creating false converts.

This leads right into the fourth mark discussed: a Biblical understanding of conversion. The New Testament is clear that there are those who undergo a false conversion, wherein they have an initial response to Christ that over time is revealed to be a false conversion. Jesus ministered to some people just like this. Understanding what it means to be born again is essential to building a healthy body of believers.

Fifth is a biblical understanding of evangelism, which combines the previous two points. Knowing the message and what it looks like for someone to be converted will set the course for how we bear witness to Christ.

The sixth mark is a biblical understanding of church membership. Mark Dever is a Baptist pastor. His clear and biblical teaching in this area helped me move from ‘membership is something Baptists do’ to ‘membership is the intentional practice of clear biblical principles.’

The seventh mark is the practice of biblical church discipline. Thinking through how the church is supposed to respond to sin in its midst is very important. If we ignore sin, we rob the church of its power and witness. Yet if we are harsh or self-righteous in dealing with people who struggle, we become legalistic pharisees. It is important we learn the Bible’s approach to this matter, so we can avoid both errors.

The eighth mark is a concern for discipleship and growth. Part of the Great Commission is teaching them to observe all that I have commanded. Once people are saved, they need taught what the Christian life looks like. That is what discipleship is all about, moving people from spiritual infancy to being spiritual providers. Healthy churches are committed to this process.

Finally, healthy churches seek to establish biblical church leadership. If the leadership is not spiritually qualified, in submission to God’s work, or lack a clear understanding of God’s vision for His people, the church will struggle to become the kind of church described in the New Testament.

Are these the only marks of a healthy church?

This book was written in 2000 and addressed some of the sweeping challenges facing the church at the time. 9marks ministries, which was born out of the response to its publication, openly recognizes that there are other important Biblical markers of health not addressed in the book. IN recent years, they have given important emphasis to prayer and missions. So, this book is not the end-all-be-all. But it is very helpful.

Can I disagree with something in the book?

The challenge of recommending books is that people may think I blindly adhere to every aspect of it. But there is only one book, the Bible, that holds true with. This book is no different. The Biblical church leadership model 9marks promotes is a form of elder-led congregationalism. They basically argue that if a church does not follow this model, they are not functioning biblically. Although I have learned a lot from this book and the broader ministry of 9marks, I do not fully agree with them in this area of teaching.

Further reading

If an area of the book piques your interest that you would like to explore further, 9marks has put out companion books on each subject. For a full list of books and articles, as well as podcasts and other resources, you can check out 9marks.org. They have several helpful resources.

What if I do not have time to read a 250 page book?

If you want to explore the points of this book but do not have time for a longer read, I highly recommend Mark Dever’s book What is a Healthy Church? It is a condensed and simplified version of the longer book.

God cares about the structure and function of the church. That is why He taught about it in the Bible. This book is a helpful resource in understanding some important aspects of our corporate life together as His followers. I highly recommend it. Happy reading!

Pigs and Pearls

Matthew 7:6 Do not give what is holy to dogs, and do not throw your pearls before swine, or they will trample them under their feet, and turn and tear you to pieces.

This statement, which reads like a Jewish proverb, appears towards the end of the Sermon on the Mount. At first glance it can appear as a random statement disjointed from the flow of the sermon. But after closer examination, it fits the context well.

Prior to this statement, Jesus said do not judge so that you will not be judged (7:1). By this, Jesus meant we are to avoid passing unnecessary, harsh, or hypocritical judgment on others. Yet that does not mean believers should never evaluate (judge) people or circumstances. A few verses later (vs. 15-20), Jesus warned us of false teachers, whom we can identify by the fruits of their lives. We are to evaluate them, not by our standards, but by the standards of God’s word. In other words, there is a sinful form of judgment we are to avoid, but there is an appropriate judgment we are to practice.

The verse we are considering follows Jesus’ statements on passing wrong judgment on people. It reminds us that ‘not judging’ does not mean we ignore sin or opposition to the gospel. Instead, we are to be wise stewards of the gospel, calling people to faith in Jesus without holding the message of His salvation up for distain.

Dogs and pigs were the two most despicable animals in Jewish culture. Dogs were mangy scavengers; not pets like they are for us. They ate whatever they could find and roamed wherever they chose. If a Jew really wanted to insult someone, they would call them a dog. Pigs were deemed unclean by the law, meaning they were a part of the dietary restrictions God put on the Jews in the OT. Over time, they came to be seen as the figurehead, not only for all the unclean animals, but for everything that is despicable to God. With these two animals, Jesus is pointing his listeners to the most vile things they could imagine.

Jesus said to withhold what is holy from a dog. This is probably a reference to the ‘holy food’ in the temple that only priests could eat. Jesus is saying that we are not to take what is consecrated for the service of God and feed it to dogs who will devour it with no regard for its sacredness. In the process of devouring it, they may turn and devour you. This paints the imagery of a pack of dogs attacking food with no regard for the one feeding them.

Nor are we to place our pearls before swine. Pigs do not understand the value of pearls, so they will trample them as worthless if placed before them. I know someone who was working cattle in a sloppy pen, when his wedding ring fell off among the cattle. They trampled over it before he could retrieve it, so it was lost. That is the picture here. Pigs will trample the pearls so that they are lost. This is not how we treat something of value.

So, what is the holy food and precious pearls we are to protect rather than treat with contempt? It is the gospel. In 2 Corinthians 4 describes the gospel as a treasure God has placed in jars of clay, which are His people. That passage talks about the distain the world shows for the gospel and how they attack its messengers. It is a wonderful parallel to this verse.

Jesus is saying that we should not intentionally expose the gospel to ridicule. We believe that everyone is redeemable; and we want everyone to have the opportunity to believe in Christ. We also understand that it is our responsibility to share the gospel with lost people. Yet wisdom is necessary to know when and where we are to share the gospel, and when it is unwise to share it.

If someone is clearly hardened against and unresponsive to the gospel, it dishonors God to provoke such a person’s blasphemous response to God by poking them with the gospel. This does not mean we stop praying for them or looking for ways to soften them towards Christ. It is simply a recognition that the Holy Spirit has work to do on their heart before they will respond positively, so we are going to wait for a more opportune time.

Furthermore, we do not intentionally create circumstances where we will be persecuted. We do not try to provoke people to attack us, lest the gospel be ridiculed, and we be destroyed in the process. I am not going to go to Mecca during Islam’s annual pilgrimage there, stand on one of the pillars of their mosque, and preach Christ with a bullhorn. It will not have the results I desire; and it will result in my imprisonment or worse. There are better ways to reach those individuals with the message of salvation than that.

I saw this principle worked out simultaneously in two churches response to a challenge. During Ontario’s government mandated cessation of church services a few years ago, a church decided they could no longer comply and would resume services before they had governmental sanction to do so. Before their first gathering, they called the mayor of the city, the local health department, and the police to tell them when and where they would gather and to invite them to join them. To no one’s surprise, the police were on sight, fines were issued, and court cases were fought.

Around the same time, a different church also decided they could no longer cease gathering, so they organized ‘underground’ gatherings in homes, barns, and sheds. Those who attended were prepared to suffer the consequences if the police arrived; but they also tried to be discreet because all they wanted was to worship God according to their consciences.

Both churches claimed that their actions were motivated by their belief in the gospel. Yet in one circumstance, it felt like a political fight. The church gathering became the battleground on which the fight was waged. In the other circumstance, it felt like people trying to worship God according to their conscience. To me, it seemed like the gospel was adorned by the humble obedience of one group, while in the other circumstance the gospel was needlessly subjected to scorn, not because they chose to gather, but in the manner in which they chose to do so.

Believers are ambassadors of Christ through whom God is making the appeal of salvation to the world. But like a good ambassador, we need to remember that our goal is to woo people to Christ by showing the glory of His salvation. We need wisdom to know when to take the pearl of the gospel from our pocket, so we can say we beg you on behalf of Christ, be reconciled to God (2 Cor. 5:20); and we need wisdom to know when sharing the gospel will only result in ridicule of His name and needless danger to us. We should be prepared to suffer and even die for the gospel, but we do not look for opportunities to prove our willingness to do so.